Academic Journals Database
Disseminating quality controlled scientific knowledge

An analysis of accuracy and reliability of emergency department ECG interpretations

Author(s): Mustafa SEVER | Özgür KARCIOĞLU | Özgür ASLAN | Fidan SEVER | İsmet PARLAK | Murat ERSEL

Journal: Turkish Journal of Emergency Medicine
ISSN 1304-7361

Volume: 7;
Issue: 2;
Start page: 56;
Date: 2007;

Keywords: Emergency department | emergency physician | electrocardiography.

Objectives: To determine the accuracy and reliability of emergency physician (EP) interpretations of ECGs obtained in the emergency department (ED). Materials and Methods: 300 consecutive adult patients of whom ECGs had been obtained in the ED were enrolled in the study. One patient was excluded due to misreplacement of ECG electrodes. Tracings were blindly analyzed and allocated into three categories (Category I: clinically insignificant abnormalities, Category II: potentially significant abnormalities and Category III: clinically significant ECG pathologies) by an EP and a second interpretation by a staff cardiologist as the gold standard. ECG interpretation concordance of EP and cardiologist was evaluated using kappa test.Results: Discrepancies of interpretations of abnormal ECGs between EP and cardiologists were 42.2%. Ten (3.3%) of these were within Category III, 22 (7.3%) were in Category II and 95 (31.6%) in Category I. The most frequently missed findings were nonspecific ST-T segment elevation and atrial enlargment or hypertrophy. Total rate of discordance was 49.2% including misinterpretations of normal ECGs (n=148, p
Why do you need a reservation system?      Affiliate Program