Academic Journals Database
Disseminating quality controlled scientific knowledge

The Three R’s of Seeking Transitional Justice: Reparation, Responsibility, and Reframing in Canada and Argentina

ADD TO MY LIST
 
Author(s): Michelle Bonner | Matt James

Journal: International Indigenous Policy Journal
ISSN 1916-5781

Volume: 2;
Issue: 3;
Start page: 1;
Date: 2011;
Original page

Keywords: transitional justice | reparations | Indigenous peoples | truth commissions | colonialism | Argentina | Canada

ABSTRACT
Indigenous children in state-organized and funded residential schools raises profound and in many ways quite novel questions about transitional justice concerning Indigenous peoples in advanced capitalist societies. This article compares the Canadian case with that of a quintessential transitional justice pioneer: Argentina.Focusing on the efforts of justice-seekers in each country, it reveals similarities in their respective pursuits of what the article identifies as three important transitional justice goals: reparation, responsibility and reframing. However, the article also finds a crucial difference between the two cases. This difference is that justice seekers in Argentina have placed a heavy emphasis on social and political accountability, a goal that, in various ways, has received much less attention in the Canadian case. We conclude that this absence raises broader issues about transitional justice processes in countries marked by ongoing legacies of anti-Indigenouscolonialism—issues that Canadians from the settler society, in particular, must begin urgently to address.

Tango Rapperswil
Tango Rapperswil

     Affiliate Program